July
18
Today's
itinerary was simply to return to Guilin, but the group
decided it wanted to check out the landscape of the Li
River. Around noon, the group tried to rent a boat and
travel up the river against the current. With this effort
unsuccessful, they had no choice but to rent a mid-size
bus.
They
joked around in a mellow manner while on the bus, telling
stories of the Long March to Guangxi artists Zhou Shaobo
and Wei Jun. Zhou and Wei said that the other exhibitions
they had participated in were the type that are set up
and taken down at the same time; Long March is different,
they said, because after an artist takes part in one stage,
the core crew moves along to the next. Leaving an artist
behind is no problem. The two curators explained that
they hoped these two artists would continue to take part
in Long March in a special way, turning Guangxi into a
base. The curators also gave them two editions of Sui
Jianguo's "Jesus in a Mao Suit" statue, trusting
them to install these objects near the church in Nanning.
Once they reached Nanning in the afternoon, Zhou and Wei
helped the group arrange its accommodations, and reluctantly
went on their way.
That
evening, it was discovered that the portable GPS reader
needed for Ingo Gunther's work had been left on the bus,
so the group quickly gave a call back to Yangshuo to recover
it. The manager of the hotel in Yangshuo, still earnestly
distributing Long March postcards even after the group
had moved on, took on a serve-the-people attitude and
circled the city searching for the gadget.
July
19
Lu
Jie flew to Kunming in advance of the group to take part
in at the opening of the Upriver Loft. The exhibition
contained works by Liu Hong and Fu Liya. This was the
first of many Long March activities in Kunming. For this
exhibition, Fu Liya had completed the first part of her
work Water Asking, which would soon be continued in dialogue
with Judy Chicago at Lugu Lake. People had obtained artificial
eyelashes from Fu Liya. Male and female participants deconstructed
the pleasing characteristics of these objects by attaching
them to their faces in "wrong places." The participants
also answered a questionnaire Fu had prepared on feminism,
using blue and white strips of paper. Fu locked the answers
in a glass bottle, and asked Lu Jie to seal it.
Qiu
Zhijie and the ranks of the marchers boarded the train.
Immediately prior to boarding, they recovered the GPS
reader from a kind-hearted Yangshuo bus driver. Recovering
the gadget, which stored data from the first three stops
along the Long March, added a comic element to the journey,
searching, and memory themes of the Guangxi stage of the
exhibition.
"Qu
Guangci" raised some concerns while trying to get
his sculpture through the train station's security checkpoint.
His bag was opened and searched, and only after he explained
that he was carrying the sculpture for a TV show was he
able to clear the checkpoint. Aboard the train, everyone
slept right away, making up for lost sleep.
American
artist Judy Chicago and her husband Donald Woodman arrived
in Beijing. Lisa Horikawa, Guo Yu, Xiao Liu, and Yang
Tao got busy with the preparations for her coming lecture
at The Loft.
July
20
The
Long Marchers arrived in Kunming, and settled into the
Haofan Hotel, near the Upriver Loft. They met up with
participating artists Ma Han and He Chi who had arrived
earlier.
That
afternoon, the Long March occupied the Upriver Loft office
of owner Ye Yongqing, turning it into a base of operations.
A delegation from the Long March Foundation New York arrived,
including Shen Meng, Lu Jie's wife. She brought with her
the latest results of the Long March Propaganda Team's
work in Xu Bing's Brooklyn home-studio: a Long March logo
designed by Xu Bing in his New English Calligraphy. The
Propaganda Team members who helped with the logo included:
Wang Gongxin and Lin Tianmiao, Shen Meng and her children,
Cai Guoqiang's wife Wu Honghong and daughter Cai Wenyou,
Chen Zhen's wife Xu Min, the biologist Yu Congrong, Ma
Limei and others. Xu Bing also designed a special badge
for the Long March, featuring a hammer, a sickle, and
a calligraphy brush. Qiu Zhijie immediately got on his
computer and used the new materials to design Long March
T-shirts, flags, and stickers. He burnt these onto a CD
and sent Ma Han to have them printed. In this way, the
Long March gained a propaganda tool other than the original
postcards, new materials that could be quickly distributed
to passers-by. The working efficiency of the "Central
Red Army" was enough to make observers faint in amazement.
Later
in the afternoon, "Qu Guangci," carrying his
statue of Qu Guangci, paid visits one by one to the Upriver
Loft studios of artists Duan Yuhai, Luan Xiaojie, Liu
Jianhua, and Ye Yongqing, as well as the studio of visiting
British artist Chris Jones.
July
21
Prior
to the group's arrival, Ye Yongqing had been in contact
with Jiangwutang Military School about the use of their
space.
Yunnan
Southern Army Jiangwutang Military School (Jiangwutang
means "hall of emphasizing military affairs")
was built in the late Qing Dynasty, and remains a key
national-level cultural preservation site. It was one
of the earliest Western-style military academies in China.
Most of its students were members of Sun Yatsen's fraternal
organization, and the school played an important role
in the 1911 uprising that overthrew Qing rule as well
as the "Protect the Nation" movement several
years later. It is the alma mater of PRC heroes Zhu De
and Ye Jianying. The former site of the campus is now
divided into three parts. One part has been rented to
an extracurricular school for young people, one part remains
as a museum of revolutionary history, and the third part
is being converted into a long-term exhibition space for
the works of early communist photographer Fang Suya. The
Long March picked this site for an exhibition called Indoctrination,
which was held just outside the history museum. All of
the works exhibited there were installations having to
do with the idea of the classroom, looking to interrogate
the changes in both Chinese traditional education and
the Western educational model, and thinking about reactions
to the process of modernization.
Ye
Yongqing and his wife Fu Liya came early to Jiangwutang
to assist the Long March team in installing the exhibition.
The display room in the museum of revolutionary history
was quickly converted into an exhibition hall for Long
March works. As soon as the works were hung, the historical
meaning of the site came alive. The walls of the room
in which the Prisoners' Ink Wash Works Cases series by
Zhu Qingsheng and others was displayed were filled with
images of revolutionary martyrs. As these "martyrs"
were prisoners in their own day, venue and works were
able to merge into a cohesive whole. Xu Bing's aides,
the "Long March Propaganda Team," pasted the
New English Calligraphy Long March logo all around the
first exhibition hall. The pictures on the walls in this
room were of the late Qing Yunnan Revolution, and across
from these was the saying "Live Honorably, Die Gloriously"
in the calligraphy of Mao Zedong. This original space
raised the question of "indoctrination," and
continually preserved a tripartite discursive tension
among tradition, revolution, and modernity.
The
exhibition having been installed, the marchers moved to
the Upriver Loft, where in the second floor display room
they re-installed the Li Tianbing-Li Jincheng Father-Son
Photography Exhibition from Ruijin, the Long March's first
site.
This
exhibition was re-installed because it pertained to questions
the Long March wished to discuss about the situation of
artists in Kunming. In recent years, Kunming's artistic
circle has been extraordinarily active. There is now an
old factory on Xiba Road that is home to Jingpin Gallery,
The Upriver Loft, The Nautica Center, and the studios
of Pan Dehai and more than 30 other famous painters. Houxin
Avenue is home to the Upriver Art Club, a multi-purpose
club that includes a dormitory, studios, a caf¨¦, and a
small exhibition hall. These artistic facilities, combined
with the new community of artists' studios in Dali and
the Muwangfu Post Station in Lijiang, constitute a group
of resources that is widely shared, creating a strong
artistic network. Moreover, these facilities have built
friendly, cooperative relationships with local government
and media. These artists have built a self-sufficient,
though not isolated, artistic system outside the so-called
"art centers" of Beijing and Shanghai. And due
to the international experience and connections of leading
figure Ye Yongqing, this Yunnan art network is fairly
globalized. When the Long March team arrived in Kunming,
young British artists Chris Jones and Pauline Thomas were
working in their studios at the Upriver Loft, and living
in the Upriver Art Club. Their ongoing exhibition Right
and Wrong, then taking place at the Upriver Loft, was
included in an August 3 Long March exhibition.
The
art scene in Yunnan is characterized by its relaxed and
cooperative attitude, as well as its active development
and utilization of all local social resources. This makes
it an interesting starting point for a global dialogue,
as well as a prototype for the maturing art system throughout
China. It relates to photographer Li Tianbing, who, in
the absence of electric power, shot all of his photographs
with natural light, exemplifying a spirit of self-dependence.
The Long March will raise this question once more in the
Northern Shaanxi city of Nanniwan.
At
night, Yunnan artists met at the Upriver Art Club, where
they heard a lecture from Lu Jie introducing the activities
of the Long March during its first three stages. Qiu Zhijie
kept busy projecting pictures with his computer. After
the talk, Qiu hurried to the dental hospital to fix a
toothache that had been bothering him all day.
July
22
This
afternoon, the Indoctrination exhibition opened at Jiangwutang
Military School.
Xu
Bing's New English Calligraphy Long March stickers were
laid out one by one on the windowsills. Viewers were encouraged
to take the brushes and ink which had been prepared and
try their hand at writing in this script. Shen Maotou,
Long March Propaganda Team member and son of Shen Meng,
had studied New English Calligraphy under Xu Bing in New
York. He became a "little teacher" at Jiangwutang,
teaching other children how to write the characters.
Displayed
in the same room as Xu Bing's New English Calligraphy
was Wang Jinsong's video work, One History Class of Mine.
After sitting before the camera for ten minutes without
expression, the artist begins to write one line on the
blackboard: "An accomplished fact cannot be contested."
In
the second hall was Ma Han's work White Shirt Drawing
Seminar. Ma Han starched a set of eighteen white shirts,
molding them to resemble bodiless statues. The shirts
were hung in midair like flying birds, and a group of
school children holding sketchbooks were seated underneath.
Ma Han gave the kids an onsite lesson in charcoal drawing.
After the sketching session was over, the shirts were
distributed one per student as a "homework assignment."
Ma Han asked the students to draw directly on the shirts
and return them to him as the third phase of this work.
After distributing the shirts, Ma Han led the assembled
viewers in recreating a scene from a famous Cultural Revolution
era print of a struggle session entitled Blood Clothing
by Wang Shikuo. Ye Yongqing willingly played the part
of the old landlord being criticized in the picture. Lu
Jie, posing as chairman, answered questions from the film
crew, introducing the notion of curating by talking about
the meaning of spatial and historical context and artistic
education. In this re-enactment "blood clothing"
was replaced by a clean white shirt; the shift symbolized
the end of the connection between art and change.
In
the third hall were two old works, Zhang Peili's classic
video Standard Pronunciation-Water Cihai and Song Dong's
Another Class, Are You Willing to Play with Me?
In
the fourth hall, He Chi worked on his Large Character
Pinyin Teaching Materials. He Chi rewrote thirty of Mao
Zedong's poems using characters with the same pronunciation
but different meanings from the originals, printing a
set of posters to be hung in a classroom and a set of
low-priced textbooks on cheap paper. A sunflower blossom
was placed on each desk, and viewers sat on top of the
blossoms, using the textbooks that lay open on the floor
to follow He Chi in a guided reading of the poems. The
children in the class had not previously studied Mao's
Poem "Seven Rules, One Long March," so they
were introduced to this history in an auditory experience
with a set of identical sounds with variant meanings.
In
the fifth hall, Zhu Qingsheng, Zhu Yan, Kong Chang'an,
and Ding Binhe collaborated to produce the Prisoners'Ink
Wash Works Cases series. These four artists realized this
work long ago, in 1986, when they were graduate students
at the Central Academy of Fine Arts. The work is conducted
in a manner similar to a sociological survey. Ink washes
are used as an educational tactic for Beijing prisoners.
Different prisoners' individual characteristics become
visible on paper, bringing out the differences between
amateurs and professionals, expressionists and aesthetes,
regulated and divergent personalities. The exhibition
included working photos, class outlines, and communications
from Zhu Qingsheng and others. One handkerchief on which
a prisoner had drawn a landscape scene was particularly
able to attract the gaze of viewers. This exhibition would
continue at Jiangwutang Military School for one week.
That
evening Lu Jie and Qiu Zhijie held a meeting at the Upriver
Loft with the female artists who were to take part in
the upcoming exhibition at Lugu Lake. They talked continuously
of the substance and arrangement of the works to be exhibited.
August
2
The
Long Marchers split into two groups, some heading to Kunming
by plane and others by bus. Commander-in-chief Lu Jie
and deputy Qiu Zhijie took the plane in order to quickly
get started on their next set of operations in Kunming.
Those going back on the bus caught up on their sleep during
the 9-hour bus ride through the backwoods of Yunnan province.
With their last visit still fresh in mind, the marchers
felt at home back in Kunming.
Ma
Han arrived in Kunming earlier than the curatorial team
to begin preparing his work for the next site, on the
train from Kunming to Zunyi, scheduled for August 6, in
his hotel room. He transformed the entire room into a
chaotic studio, enough to scare away the maid, whom he
did not see for days. He planned to lend train passengers
old books from the 1960s, 70s and 80s, giving them a chance
to rekindle memories of those years through tangible objects.
A huge movable bookshelf had been placed between the two
beds, and hundreds of books covered the floor.
August
3
Installation
began on a sound art exhibition at Luo Xu's The Native's
Nest. As soon as the Long March curators arrived, the
first thing they saw was Luo Xu himself and a pile of
slogans chaotically littering the side of the street.
Some had been written in lacquer directly onto the concrete
ground, others were inscribed on paper. The characters
were one meter high each, written in bold colors and strong
fonts, and the content was a poem about the Long March
by Mao Zedong and other Red Army slogans. Just inside
the entrance was a sofa, on top of which was a note that
read: "this sofa is the property of individual behavior;
non-Long March activities not permitted." Luo Xu's
naughty child demeanor and arbitrary and complicated personality
vividly came to the surface.
Luo
Xu is a sculptor in the tradition of the Yi minority,
who several years ago borrowed millions of RMB to build
a sculpture garden on the outskirts of Kunming. Called
a sculpture "nest," this appellation accurately
describes the character of the place; it was pieced together
like a bird pieces together a nest. The rumor is that
Luo first used white ash to paint a circle on this mountain
slope, and then instructed the construction crew to build
wherever he placed bamboo poles. It collapsed multiple
times during the construction process, scaring the workers.
Finally, multiple unsuccessful efforts led to an ideal
structure, which looks like a loaf of steamed bread from
outside, and appears from inside as if height, width,
and depth have been set at random, creating the effect
of a maze. The larger rooms mostly have domed ceilings,
supported by girders in a cathedralesque manner. Light
comes through skylights and holes set into the walls.
This piece of architecture, which has grown like a plant,
has become a display hall for Luo Xu's sculptures, in
which works he has created over nearly twenty years in
all imaginable sculptural styles are scattered into nearly
every corner. The most conspicuous work in the place takes
a thigh as its main element, and has an obvious air of
life-worship to it, enhanced by and enhancing the arched
ceiling, full of mystical power.
In
the earlier process of investigating sites for the Long
March, Lu Jie and Qiu Zhijie made a preliminary visit
to Luo Xu, and were stirred by the combination of his
sculptures and their environment, moved by the way in
which this man creates like an ant-king. He made them
think of the palace of found objects built by that harbinger
of surrealism Ferdinand Cheval. This sort of artistic
site could not be shipped off and exhibited in an art
"center" like Venice, Kassell, Beijing, or Shanghai.
To contact this work of art, one must come directly to
the scene, must experience it firsthand. On this account,
the Long March curators especially chose to hold here
the sort of activity that is most dependent on firsthand
experience-a sound installation exhibition. The special
geographic situation and architectural layout of Luo Xu's
nest made it ideal for this sort of exhibition. The curators
hoped to draw on both of these strengths, and to create
value for the "site" out of the significance
of the local culture and the physical location.
Works
by Yu Xiaofeng, Ren Qian, and Ma Jie had already been
installed, and interactive works by Li Chuan and Li Yong
were still being installed. These five artists from Chongqing
were also participants in China's first true sound art
exhibition, held one year ago at the Mustard Seed Garden
in Beijing, members of China's first generation of experimental
sound artists. All are incredibly young, though their
works grow more mature by the day. Their work on the site
let the organizers relax, so the Long March team retreated
to the city in order to prepare for that night's opening
reception.
That
night at the Loft there would be three activities: the
Exhibition about an Exhibition at the Upriver Loft; an
exhibition at the Nordica Center next door to last year's
"Dali Ink Painting Studio" combined with an
ink painting session; and an open studio exhibition by
all of the artists living in the Loft complex. The result
would be a large-scale open exhibition at the Loft, including
a reportative exhibition by two visiting British artists,
Chris Jones and Pauline Thomas, entitled Reality and Falsehood.
Exhibition
about an Exhibition collected works by several popular
Chinese easel painters, but arranged them according to
a curatorial principal of circularity. In terms of works,
this meant showing not the most well-known works, but
works that showed the creative background, materials,
and vestiges of the artists' earlier works, looking more
at the process behind their "finished products"
than the products themselves. In terms of artist selection,
this meant choosing artists with no prior connection to
the Loft in Kunming.
For
example, Zhang Xiaogang, who explores the contemporary
soul of China in paintings that have the flare of old
photographs, was represented in this exhibition by a series
of actual photographs entitled Credentials. Unfortunately,
a planned installation by Zhang Xiaogang entitled My Mother
Country was not completed due to time constraints. The
Credentials series includes photographs of several dozen
IDs and certificates held by Zhang since his childhood,
including his student ID from Sichuan Academy of Fine
Arts, blood donor card, China Artists' Association membership
card, marriage license, work license, graduation certificate
from a short course on Marxist theory, and more recent
driver's license, property deed, and a temporary residence
permit for Beijing. The fact that the blank for "reason
for coming to Beijing" on the residence permit is
filled in "economic and commercial activities"
makes the viewer think of Zhang Xiaogang's paintings and
his fame. In addition to being extremely comical, this
also makes the viewer think deeply about the unceasing
rigidity with which society seeks to categorize people.
An individual life is contained and controlled on all
sides by a society stratified and divided into specialties,
trapped in the complex webs of economy and ideology. Though
the pictures in Credentials are all of the standard "passport
photo" variety, what the installation reveals is
the many masks a single person wears in relation to society.
"Credentials" showed the multiplicity required
by society's many requirements of its members even as
it exhibited relics of the destruction implicit in the
processes of individual maturation and social change.
The system of authority whereby existing power structures
have the power to determine identity also exerts an untraceable
influence on the artist, creating a sort of restructuring
amidst all the disintegration. Credentials presents traces
of Zhang Xiaogang's personal career, and like his Big
Family series of oil paintings, it ineffably faces the
vicissitudes of the individual in relation to society.
During
the activities in Sichuan, Ye Yongqing earned the title
of "scout hero." He is a knight who has traveled
far and wide to bring back for his Yunnan paesani an understanding
of the international art scene. Every time Ye Yongqing,
or General Ye as his friends call him, returns to China,
those around him love to hear his stories about the world
beyond. He has already filled five passports. These filled
passports show him off not as a traveler, but as someone
with a broad international vision, with a fine tuned plan
for his own locality. He is an artist's artist, and for
that reason he created the Upriver Loft space in Kunming
where the current exhibition was about to be held. His
installation From Here to There was the story of himself
and the Upriver Loft: photocopied renditions of each of
his passport pages created a long aisle along the floor,
with a color photograph at the beginning and end of this
aisle. At the beginning was a picture of an old factory,
the site of the Upriver Loft before it was restored. In
the middle was Ye Yongqing's own studio, brightly adorned
with a few of his childish and natural paintings. The
final photograph, at the end of the row of copied visas,
was of the first exhibition held in the Upriver Loft after
its restoration, a show of works by students entitled
Unfinished. The photo depicts students standing in the
space bearing placards that read "unfinished,"
the motto of this international traveler. Pasted amidst
this mosaic of international travel was Ye Yongqing's
personal artistic world, on the one hand linking with
society's timeworn dicta, on the other connecting to the
opening of space and the advent of new activities.
In
one corner of the Upriver Loft, a tape of an interview
with painter Song Yonghong attracted attention. A computer
on a table showed slides of daily life amongst the Beijing
artists' community: studios, kitchens, studios. It showed
a system of personal relationships constantly in flux,
a sort of common knowledge base, an excessively specialized
system of identity, stratified along many different lines:
age, place of origin, personality and experience, fame,
money, even food preferences and artistic style.
Chengdu
painter Yang Mian displayed a computer generated cartoon
of an "ideal residential community," sarcastically
mixing his terror and worry over the "beautiful new
world." Kunming painter Zhang Zhongqi used a camera
to record the lonely and quiet daily life of a former
Red Army soldier.
Yang
Shaobin's photographs Friends were taken to assist him
in creating oil paintings. The photos show people fighting
viciously and friends of the artist. Yue Minjun's video
installation, on the other hand, did not initially resemble
his paintings. It showed a visit to an elementary school
in a poor mountain village, the lens repeatedly flashing
in the students' dirty faces, tattered clothing, and simple
gazes. They reminded the viewer of the faces in Yue Minjun's
paintings, as the children's grins and laughter looked
wise and sagacious in the context of utter poverty.
Another
wall of The Loft was filled with small works left by the
international artists who had previously lived and worked
in the space: Bao Li's video Birds; Lisa's material work
Jewelry; and Takahashi Tomoko's photomontage. The presentation
of these works in combination with the open studio exhibitions
taking place combined to present the history of The Loft
over the past few years in a single exhibition.
At
7:30, people assembled in the Upriver Loft. After Ye Yongqing
had introduced Lu Jie and Qiu Zhijie, he especially introduced
Shen Meng who had come all the way from New York. She
is one of the creators of the Long March foundation and
an important participant in the Long March's activities
in Kunming. She was the maker of a work depicting the
Long March Propaganda Team's activities the previous week
at Jiangwutang Military School in Kunming. Her appearance
elicited a round of applause. After the opening ceremony,
people moved next door to Sweden's Nordica Center to participate
in another Long March activity: Degeneration: Works by
the Dali Ink Painting Studio.
The
Dali Ink Painting Studio was opened two years ago by Li
Xianting and Ye Yongqing, and was funded by Soo Bin Chua
of Singapore with the aim of creating a modern genre of
ink painting. Zhang Xiaogang, Zhou Chunya, Mao Xuhui,
Fang Lijun, Liu Wei, Wang Guangyi, Yue Minjun, and Yang
Shaobin are some of the famous oil panters who have participated
in the project, converging on Dali for a week of ink painting.
These painters, all trained in the Western academic style,
ran into the problem that the very materials of Chinese
ink and wash painting raised their expectations, and creating
in this sort of collective studio atmosphere caused the
painters to reflect on their own education. They wondered
whether the creation-display model was truly the only
paradigm for artistic creation, whether other ways of
playing the game existed, perhaps psychological frameworks
that would incorporate local culture. Thinking about these
questions, people came to appreciate the many works of
alternative ink and wash painting on display at the Nordica
Center. From beginning to end, the viewers looked to the
works for traces of classic ink and wash, ever and again
looking to the paintings for a connection with old styles,
and feeling astonished at this break with tradition.
This
"gathering of scholars" style of exchange made
the curators of the Long March quite happy, and so, at
20:30 that evening, there began an ink painting session.
Lu Jie, who began as a student of Chinese painting, painted
a Red Army flag waving in the grasslands of a snowy mountain.
Picking up where he left off, Zhang Xiaogang added the
overcast eyes often seen in his paintings, and Yue Minjun,
Mao Xuhui, and Cai Simin one by one took turns. This precious
sheet of rice paper became invaluable, and after the painters
had all added their contributions, Lu Jie's son Maotou
and Zhang Xiaogang's daughter Huanhuan had a chance to
paint.
At
22:30 that evening, the children had grown tired as the
adults sat in the Upriver Loft drinking and chatting.
The large sheet from the ink painting session contained
traces of everyone present. A slightly drunk Qiu Zhijie
took his place at the front of the table and coined a
verse of doggerel directed at Upriver Loft owner Ye Yongqing.
The poem read: "The Red Army doesn't fear distance
or disorder, because the Upriver Loft is their headquarters."
Ye Yongqing responded that "the event's over, there's
no need to keep sucking up." Everyone broke out into
laughter, and with that went their separate ways.
August 4
At
midday Kunming artists rendezvoused at the Loft and boarded
a bus for Luo Xu's museum The Native's Nest. Upon arrival
they discovered that the previous night's rain had already
ruined the slogans written on paper and taped to the floor
outside the museum. Characters that had been written on
those papers stayed imprinted on the cement ground, making
everyone laugh. The sound exhibition took up three rooms
of the maze-like gallery.
In
the large room, Luo Xu's clay sculptures were displayed
in rows like members of a choir. The raised dome ceiling
of the hall gave the feeling of a church, and here were
projected several video works relating to sound that had
been brought along by the Long March ranks.
Wang
Gongxin's Karaoke, from a technological perspective, was
foremost a visual game. A lens approaching a mouth shows
huge teeth, forcing the viewer into a state of physiological
discomfort. Digital enhancement had placed images of people
singing into microphones onto each of the teeth. Particularly
striking was the image of a bare-chested male singer,
who carried associations of the vernacular culture of
Beijing's alleyway denizens. Putting these images inside
of a mouth formed a violent contrast: the mouth, a necessarily
sanitary and extremely personal space transformed into
a public space, a venue for entertainment. The people
singing karaoke use their own mouths to produce similar
sounds. In imitation of the moving noise icons on karaoke
videodiscs, which invited viewers to sing along. This
video actually invaded the mouth of one viewer. Intricate
sound editing is a specialty of Wang Gongxin's works,
and the work was successful in that the loud screams lead
to subconscious imitation.
Wu
Ershan completed a work for a Jazz stage entitled Evolution
Jazz, its screen filled with dizzying numbers and all
sorts of scribbles. Accompanying this work was Chen Dili's
MiDi-produced music, which turned The Native's Nest into
a very strange place.
Chen
Xiaoyun's Who is an Angel is a classic example of the
inversion of sound and image. The image portrays people
hopping in many different situations, but because the
floor has been digitally removed from below them, they
appear to be jumping in midair. The images were set to
the sound of barking dogs, at once inexplicable and suggestive
of a distant causal relationship.
Yang
Zhenzhong's Light as Fuck presented images of the artist
holding a shrunken version of the television tower in
Shanghai. In order to prevent the tower from toppling,
he constantly adjusts his position. His attention is concentrated
on the "famous pearl of the east" balancing
atop his fingers, leading him to make rapid subconscious
movements. The noise of his footsteps has been enhanced,
creating a threatening relationship with the rocking tower
at the center of his lens.
Zhou
Xiaohu's Nursery Rhyme was another work about vocal transmission.
Children standing in a circle repeat a sentence one to
another; when the sentence is misheard, it gets repeated
incorrectly, sometimes completely transforming in meaning.
These
videos, from a psychological, physical, and social perspective
reflected the important role which sound plays in contemporary
art, providing a background for the several works of sound
art which premiered at The Native's Nest.
Moving
in from the main hall, viewers were led into a deep maze
by oil lamps in rough clay bowls. One dark room after
another was hung with gloomy oil lamps, with an occasional
scarecrow hung upside down in a corner. In the dark, ears
could pick up the sounds of tiny bells from afar, and
as one moved further in, the oil lamps became increasingly
frequent, to the point where the viewer consciously avoided
bumping into them. The noise of the bells also became
clearer and clearer. Tiny star-like dots of light appeared
in the distance. In the midst of this light and noise,
the viewer suddenly felt a burst of hot air, like the
breath of an animal. Borrowing on the subtle weakness
of the oil lights, viewers discovered a bull nibbling
on a scarecrow, with small bells hanging both from the
scarecrow and the bull's tail, producing noises in synch
with the bull's chewing. This work was by Ren Qian.
Compared
with the scattered nature of Ren Qian's work, Yu Xiaofeng's
Explosive Laughter seemed crazy and abrupt. In a round
space, viewers saw a large round vat full of ink and mist,
with a dozen or so small portable radios suspended above,
emitting noisy, scrambled news broadcasts. The portable
radios were hung by filament near several sticks of burning
incense, so that each time a stick burned through to the
head, it severed a filament, causing the radio to drop,
splashing into the pot of ink. The sound of the splash
ended the sound of the radio, and the space suddenly erupted
into a moment of fantastic laughter. This was an "automatic"
interactive sound work, its internal design having predicted
this sort of movement and transition. Owing to the large
quantity of incense and small tape recorders, as far as
the viewers were concerned, this sort of movement was
similarly unpredictable.
In
other spaces of The Native's Nest hang works by Li Yong,
Li Chuan, and Ma Jie.
Li
Yong's work Entering the City, Leaving the City was the
most turbulent of the entire exhibition. He whimsically
drove three three-wheeled motorcycles into the space of
the Native's Nest, the sort of motorcycles with canopy
covers very common on the far outskirts of Chinese cities.
Such vehicles make a great deal of noise and emit much
exhaust, are uncomfortable to sit upon, but are cheap
and convenient-commonplace objects in a China on its way
to wealth and happiness. Li Yong took his inspiration
for this work from the trip he made on such a vehicle
from Kunming to The Native's Nest. He shot two segments
of video, one segment moving from beyond the city into
the city, the other moving from the center of the city
toward the outskirts. The gradual changes in the scenery
narrate the differences between the city and the countryside,
the vast discrepancies between postmodern civilization
in urban cities and low standards of living just beyond
these cities. The birth pangs of economic reform and the
postmodern mixture of urban and rural give rise to restlessness
and coarseness, a demented energy and desire put clearly
before the viewer. Two televisions played the videos,
actually placed atop motorcycles, and the viewers were
forced to sit atop the motorcycles in order to view the
piece. Afterwards, the motorcycles were started up in
the space, which is quite small, as assistants dragged
the electrical cords attached to the televisions to make
for smooth riding. But this proved impossible, as the
space was filled entirely with Luo Xu's sculptures, so
the vehicles had nowhere to safely go. Furthermore, the
two vehicles often blocked each other's route. Everywhere
was congested and awkward, moving forward or backward
was equally difficult, and the roar of the vehicles filled
the viewers' ears. Movement was suppressed, and only the
desire for movement manifested itself.
Moving
from Li Yong's work, viewers came to the work of Li Chuan.
They walked through a hallway onto a red wooden path,
embedded with a row of white footsteps. Stepping on these
footprints, the space emitted sounds one by one. The dozen
or so footprints formed one sentence: "Go forward
along the road of socialism with Chinese characteristics."
Originally, sound equipment was connected below each footprint.
As each footprint was stepped upon, it would emit the
sound of a single character in the sentence. In reality,
a person could traverse the hallway without stepping on
each footprint, but viewers were intent on trying this.
The white footprints were tempting in and of themselves,
and attracted the participation of all present.
After
passing through Li Chuan's hallway, people entered a room
decorated like a conference hall. Exactly in the center
was a massive table, covered in a white tablecloth. One
large grass shoe in the style of those worn by the Red
Army, though two meters long, hung above the table, shaking
left and right. The shoe's mate was tiny in comparison,
the size of an actual grass shoe. The small shoe was installed
atop an electric toy that moved chaotically back and forth
atop the table. The exhibit used a red string to connect
the two shoes. The small mobile shoe controlled the movement
of the hanging large shoe, but the red thread still controlled
its range of motion, and the large shoe, swinging back
and forth, influenced the movement of the small shoe.
The two shoes moved in awkward but interactive relation,
an illustration of Karl Popper's idea of "situational
logic." The shadow of the large shoe covered the
tablecloth, and the electric car with the small shoe was
in its shadow. A brush had been affixed to the back of
the toy car, and the car had been filled with colored
dye, so that when the car moved, it left traces behind
on the table, like blood marks. Because the relationship
between the movement of the large and small shoes was
mutually causal, the final form of the traces left behind
on the table could not have been predicted, a sort of
authorless abstract painting. The coloring ranged from
dry to wet and light to dark, the result of artist Ma
Jie constantly adding new dye, leaving dilemmatic traces
of the vehicle's presence.
Encounter
with "influence" and "anxiety" as
core narrative principles: this was the common point among
the several sound works exhibited at The Native's Nest.
These influences and anxieties were sometimes as concrete
as a red line or an electric cord, and other times hidden
as an auditory temptation. In these works, no movement
was automatic, and the forms of influence were many, including
Long March itself as a catalyst for a sort of "red
memory." Other times the influence was a certain
kind of ideological discourse, and yet others it was a
local experience. Sometimes it was a specific technology
expressed as a component of space.
Having
come to appreciate several of the new sound works on display,
the viewers came to realize that sound is perhaps only
a pretext-the more important concepts of movement and
site.
When
people returned to the main hall of The Native's Nest,
it suddenly began to rain heavily, and water leaked in
through holes in the roof, dripping on the projectors
and computers, destroying everyone's blind faith in the
architecture of the building. The sound works were exhibited
amidst claps of thunder in a sort of interplay between
man and nature.
The
original plan for the evening was to move several kilometers
to Cuotuo Village and hold a screening of Jiang Zhi's
documentary work Shi Zhi. Cuotuo Village became famous
in the 1980s after the movie Cuotuo Years, which reflected
the situation of young intellectuals in the post-Cultural
Revolution period. Today, the village is a sea of Karaoke
bars decorated with Roman columns and "peasant"
restaurants. Many young intellectuals have become wealthy
businessmen, and the town has become a place where they
come to remember the spirit of their youth and spend money.
Jiang Zhi's documentary depicts the life of Shi Zhi, a
representative of the young intellectual poets. Shi Zhi's
poems were once circulated among young intellectuals around
the country, and the poem "Believe the Future"
consoled countless hurt and hopeless youth during the
Cuotuo years. Shi Zhi became hopeful owing to his poems,
though his body was destroyed by his ideology, and to
this day he remains in a mental institution in Beijing,
writing his life story. The curators were thrilled to
be bringing a documentary about Shi Zhi straight to Cuotuo
Village.
After
a few phone calls, the curators learned that because of
heavy rains and road repairs, the road to Cuotuo Village
was no longer passable. After much deliberation, Lu Jie
and Qiu Zhijie decided to change their plan, return to
Kunming, and show the documentary there in a young intellectuals'
restaurant. There was a massive Mao statue in the restaurant,
and the documentary was projected just below it.
August
5
The
ten-plus artists who would exhibit at Lugu Lake continued
their preparations, with the support of the Yunnan Academy
of Fine Arts. After several days of running around by
Fu Liya and Shen Yu, the exhibition appeared to be in
good shape. This exhibition was organized proactively
by participants of the Long March, without effort from
the curators (who were of course happy to see something
like this take place that would broaden the scope of the
Long March). Objectively speaking, it was yet another
example of the positive art atmosphere prevalent in Kunming.
The
museum of the Yunnan Academy of Fine Arts very openly
accepted all of the proposals by female artists at Lugu
Lake, and in a few short days, installed a very informative
documentary exhibition. To call it a documentary exhibition,
however, is not entirely accurate, as things like Judy
Chicago's prayer flags were exhibited directly in the
museum after being shown in Qidi Shanzhuang, and Sun Guojuan's
installation of cotton candy was moved from the Mosuo
people's vicinity to the exhibition site. The context
of a matriarchal society, it seemed, had disappeared only
physically; it would exist throughout conceptually. These
works would be seen as re-manifestations of the original
works. The richness and vitality of the exhibition had
people thinking about the potential of an eventual comprehensive
exhibition about the Long March project. If just the results
of the activities at Lugu Lake could be exhibited this
resplendently, and this being only 1/20th of the entire
Long March, the future seemed bright. Furthermore, since
the Long March was about creating discourse, the power
of a coherent narrative of all 20 sites might far exceed
the sum of its parts.
Liu
Hong came to Lugu Lake as an observer, a friend of artists
Fu Liya and others. This bystander raised an interesting
question: during each of the performance works realized
at Lugu Lake, video and still camera lenses were present.
Would performance art fundamentally change in nature,
lose its natural quality, owing to the presence of the
lens? But if there was not a good record, performance
could not be transmitted beyond its initial site. In the
information age, is the value of unrecorded performance
underrated? Liu Hong took a series of photographs relevant
to this question. Her photos took up a series of questions
faced also by the curators, and while her stance may have
been oppositional, in the curators' eyes, she brought
to the fore a set of unavoidable questions about the internal
contradictions of the contemporary art system, and revealed
tensions among the notions of happening, first-hand experience,
and performance which underlay the debate. Therefore,
the curators gladly provided Liu Hong with many images
to use as "fodder."
At
three that afternoon, the exhibition opened, and after
introducing the artists, Lu Jie gave a speech of thanks
to local Kunming artists for their support of the Long
March project. Fu Liya read aloud a letter left by Judy
Chicago, who had already returned to the U.S. The soft
sculpture of Qu Guangci sat quietly in the front row through
it all. Returning to Kunming, the Long Marchers thought
about all that had happened in Lugu Lake with depth and
serenity, thinking that the meaning of the Long March
had more clearly expressed itself in the space between
the works, and that it had made a pleasant atmosphere
come over the group. In the exhibition hall, the female
artists donned newly distributed Long March T-Shirts,
signing each other's, and taking group photos, even with
the two male curators.
That
evening, the Long March group invited local artists to
a banquet, and Yue Minjun brought along his digital camera,
engaging in spontaneous creation. He shot dishes, and
he shot people, almost as if establishing some connection
between the food on the table and the friends surrounding
it. Ye Yongqing worried Yue would misconstrue this as
"conceptual photography" and give up painting.
He flashed a piece of paper, the text of an incredible
story about a bird that his teenage daughter had written
in classical Chinese. The group members were amazed when
they read it, gasping in admiration.
back